DOI: 10.30729/2541-8823-2019-4-4-281-329

Download the article - PDF


Dmitriy Ogorodov
Candidate of Legal Sciences, Arbitrator of the International Commercial Arbitration Court at the Chamber of Commerce and Industry of the Russian Federation

Abstract:The article presents an interesting issue of the Russian legal doctrine, mixed contracts, and the way the research of this question was developing. The author highlighted the contribution of Kazan civil law science which had a significant input for the mixed contracts theory. The author provides the historical overview of the issue and gives an impressive literature review, discusses the main issues of the theory of mixed contracts, their elements and essential terms. The study of mixed contracts is a traditional direction of the civil law school of Kazan University. A.A. Simolin, M.Yu. Chelyshev worked a lot on the phenomenon of mixed contracts. The author also worked together with Professor M.Yu. Chelyshev and published some joint works. The approach proposed by them was useful not only for solving the problems of civil law doctrine, but also for describing a number of special issues in the development of legal practice.

References
Aivar L.K. Pravovoe polozhenie surrogatnogo materinstva v Rossii. Probely zakonodatel’stva [Legal status of surrogacy in Russia. Loopholes in legislation], // Yuridicheskij mir = Legal World, 2006, no. 2, p. 28-35. (in Russian)
Alekseev S.V. Trudovye otnosheniya v sporte: obshchaya harakteristika regulirovaniya truda sportsmenov i trenerov [Labor relations in sports: a general characteristic of labor regulation of athletes and coaches] // Pravo i gosudarstvo: teoriya i praktika = Law and State: Theory and Practice, 2016, no. 9 (141), pp. 102-106. (in Russian)
Aliev T.T. Otgranichenie nepoimenovannyh dogovorov ot smeshannyh dogovorov [Differentiation of unnamed contracts from mixed contracts] // Yurist = Lawyer, 2016, vol. 9, pp. 20-22. (in Russian)
Balzhirov B.V. Sovremennaya konstrukciya dogovora energosnabzheniya [The modern design of the energy supply contract] // Yurist = Lawyer, 2013, no. 2, pp. 3-6. (in Russian)
Barkov A.V. Pravovaya priroda dogovora social’nogo sodejstviya detyam, ostavshimsya bez popecheniya roditelej [The legal nature of the social assistance agreement for children without parental care] // Grazhdanskoe pravo = Civil Law, 2008., no. 4, pp. 25-27. (in Russian)
Barkov A.V. Dogovor kak sredstvo pravovogo regulirovaniya rynka social’nyh uslug: Monografiya [The contract as a means of legal regulation of the social services market: Monograph]. Moscow, Lawyer Publ., 2008. (in Russian)
Baturina A.A. Smeshannyj dogovor i nekotorye smezhnye grazhdansko-pravovye konstrukcii: sootnoshenie [Mixed contract and some related civil-law constructions: correlation] // Sibirskij yuridicheskij vestnik = Siberian Law Journal, 2017, no. 4, pp. 37-43. (in Russian)
Belov V.A. Grazhdanskoe pravo: Obshchaya i Osobennaya chasti: Uchebnik [Civil law: General and special parts, course book]. Moscow: Center YurInfoR Publ., 2003, pp. 179- 181, 210-211. (in Russian)
Belyaeva O.A. Pravovye problemy aukcionov i konkursov [Legal issues of auctions and tenders]. Moscow, Jurisprudence, 2011. (in Russian)
Borodkin V.G. Korporativnyj dogovor v period reformirovaniya Grazhdanskogo kodeksa RF [Corporate agreement during the reform of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation] // Zakon = Law, 2014, no. 3, pp. 160-174. (in Russian)
Braginsky M.I. Osnovy ucheniya o nepoimenovannyh (bezymyannyh) i smeshannyh dogovorah [Fundamentals of the doctrine of unnamed (unmarked) and mixed contracts]. Moscow, Statut Publ., 2007. pp. 7-8, 51-52, 58, 60, 61. (in Russian)
Braginsky M.I., Vitryansky V.V. Dogovornoe pravo: obshchie polozheniya [Contract law: general provisions]. Moscow, 1997, pp. 238, 308-323, 328-329, 331–334. (in Russian)
Braginsky M.I., Vitryansky V.V. Dogovornoe pravo. Dogovory o peredache imushchestva [Contract law. Contracts on the transfer of property]. Book 2, ed. 4. Moscow, Statut Publ., 2002 (“ConsultantPlus”). (in Russian)
Bulygin A.V., Kryukova Yu.Ya. Skrytaya ogovorka o poruchitel’stve v dogovore mezhdu yuridicheskimi licami: problemy tolkovaniya [Hidden clause on a guarantee in a contract between legal entities: interpretation problems] // Evrazijskij Pravovoj Zhurnal = Eurasian Law Journal, 2018, no 10 (125), pp. 136-138. (in Russian)
Bychkov A.I. Smeshannyj dogovor v grazhdanskom prave RF [Mixed contract in the civil law of the Russian Federation]. Moscow, Infotropic Media Publ., 2013. (in Russian)
Bychkov A.I. Raspredelenie kvartir po modeli kompleksnogo dogovora [Distribution of apartments according to the model of a complex contract] // Semejnoe i zhilishchnoe pravo = Family and Housing Law, 2012, no. 2, pp. 36-39. (in Russian)
Carro D., Juillar P. Mezhdunarodnoe ekonomicheskoe pravo: Uchebnik [International economic law: Course book], translation from French. Мoscow, International Relations Publ., 2001, p. 554-567. (in Russian)
Chelyshev M.Yu. Predprinimatel’skaya deyatel’nost’ v professional’nom sporte: nekotorye spornye voprosy zakonodatel’stva i praktiki [Entrepreneurial activity in professional sports: some controversial issues of law and practice] // Bizness, Menedjment i pravo = Business, Management and Law, 2003, no. 3, p. 101-106. (in Russian)
Chesalina O.V. Yuridicheskaya priroda dogovora o predostavlenii truda rabotnikov [The legal nature of the contract on the provision of labor for workers] // Zhurnal rossijskogo prava = Journal of Russian Law, 2015, no. 4, pp. 66-77. (in Russian)
Churakov R.S. Eskrou-schet po rossijskomu pravu [Escrow account in Russian law] // Zakon = Law, 2007, no. 8 (“Garant”).
Grazhdanskoe pravo: voprosy teorii i praktiki [Civil law: important issues of theory and practice], ed. V.A. Belov. Moscow, 2007, p. 413 (the author of essay 11 – Yu.A. Tarasenko). (in Russian)
Grazhdanskoe pravo: uchebnik [Civil law: Course book], ed. Prof. E.A. Sukhanov, 2nd ed., vol. 2, part 1. Moscow, BEK Publ., 1999, pp. 154, 156-163. (in Russian)
Grazhdanskoe pravo Rossii. Obschaya chast: kurs lektsij [Civil law of Russia. General part: Course of lectures], ed. O.N. Sadikov, Moscow, Yurist Publ., 2001, pp. 724-729. (in Russian)
Grazhdanskoe pravo: uchebnik [Civil Law: Course book], ed. Yu.K. Tolstoy, A.P. Sergeeva, vol. 3, 6th ed. Moscow, Prospect Publ., 2003, pp. 594-602. (in Russian)
Kommentarij Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossijskoj Federatsii (chast 2) [Commentary on the Civil Code of the Russian Federation (part two)], ed. T.E. Abova, A.Yu. Kabalkin, Moscow, Urite Publ., 2003 (“ConsultantPlus”) (the author of the commentary – S.S. Zankovsky). (in Russian)
Kommentarij Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossijskoj Federatsii (chast 2) [Commentary on the Civil Code of the Russian Federation (part two)], Edited by T.E. Abova, A.Yu. Kabalkin. Moscow, Urait Publ., 2003 (“ConsultantPlus”) (commentary by E.N. Vasilieva). (in Russian)
Kommentarij tretej chasti Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossijskoj Federatsii [Commentary on the third part of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation], ed. A.L. Makovsky, E.A. Sukhanova. Moscow, Yurist Publ., 2002 (“Garant”) (commentary, article 1211 – A.S. Komarov). (in Russian)
Kommentarij Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossijskoj Federatsii, chast 3 [Commentary on the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, part three], ed. T.E. Abova, M.M. Boguslavsky, A.G. Svetlanova. Moscow, Yrait-Izdat Publ., 2004 (“Garant”) (authors of article 1211 – E.V. Kabatova, M.M. Boguslavsky, I.S. Zykin, M.P. Bardin). (in Russian)
Kommentarij Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossijskoj Federatsii [Commentary on the Code of Civil Procedure of the Russian Federation], ed. M.S. Shakaryan. Moscow, Velby, Prospect Publ., 2003, p. 629. (in Russian)
Didenko A.A. Dogovor o pol’zovanii chasti (konstruktivnogo elementa) veshchi [An agreement on the use of a part (structural element) of a thing] // Yurist = Lawyer, 2013, no. 18, pp. 24-29. (in Russian)
Drozdov I.A. Dogovory na peredachu v pol’zovanie prirodnyh resursov [Contracts on the assignment for use of natural resources]. Moscow, Prospect Publ., 2001. (in Russian)
Dyatlova N.A. Pravovaya priroda soglasheniya o gosudarstvenno-chastnom partnerstve [The legal nature of the public-private partnership agreement] // Vestnik Sankt- Peterburgskogo universiteta = Herald of St. Petersburg University. Law, 2017, vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 306-313. (in Russian)
Efimova L.G. Bankovskie sdelki: pravo i praktika [Banking transactions: law and practice]. Moscow, 2001, pp. 243–246. (in Russian)
Efremova T.F. Novyj slovar’ russkogo yazyka. Tolkovo-slovoobrazovatel’nyj [The new dictionary of the Russian language. Interpretation and word formation]. Moscow, Russian language Publ., 2000. URL: http://www.gramota.ru. (in Russian)
Em V.S., Komarova T.E., Simolin A.V. “Chekhovskij” professor (k 125-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya kazanskogo civilista A.A. Simolina (10(22).10.1879 – 23.12.1919)) [“Chekhov type” professor (on the 125th anniversary of the birth of Kazan civilist A.A. Simolin (10(22).10.1879 – 23.12.1919))] // Zakonodatelstvo = Legislation. 2004, no. 12, pp. 75-82. (in Russian)
Eremina S.N. Imushchestvennye otnosheniya v sfere dejstviya trudovogo i grazhdanskogo prava: problemnye voprosy predmeta pravovogo regulirovaniya [Property relations in the sphere of labor and civil law: Problematic issues of the subject of legal regulation] // Rossijskaya yusticiya = Russian Justice, 2015, no 6, pp. 8-12. (in Russian)
Evstafieva I.V. Problemnye voprosy perekhoda isklyuchitel’nogo avtorskogo prava na sluzhebnye proizvedeniya [Problematic issues of the transfer of exclusive copyright to official publications] // Pravo i politika = Law and Politics, 2011, no. 11, pp. 1956–1959. (in Russian)
Fetisova E.M. Smeshannye dogovory kak realizaciya principa svobody dogovora [Mixed contracts as an implementation of the principle of freedom of contract] // Zakon = Law, 2013, no. 2, pp. 146-159. (in Russian)
Gapanovich A.V. Pravovaya priroda dogovora na uplatu organizacionnogo vznosa i ego sootnoshenie s zakonom o razmeshchenii zakazov [The legal nature of the agreement on the payment of the registration fee and its relationship with the law on placing orders] // Yurist = Lawyer, 2013, no. 1, pp. 30-33. (in Russian)
Gavrilov E.P. K voprosu ob ohrane kommercheskoj, sluzhebnoj i lichnoj tajny. Grazhdanskopravovye aspekty [On the issue of protecting trade, official and personal secrets. Civil law aspects] // Khozyajstvo i pravo = Management and law, 2003, no. 5, p. 28. (in Russian)
Gavrilov E.P. Voprosy pravovoj ohrany kommercheskoj tajny [Issues of legal protection of trade secrets] // Ekonomika i pravo = Economy and Law, 2004, no. 11, p. 3-13. Gavrilov E.P. O kommercheskoj tajne [On trade secrets], Electronic publication, prepared for “ConsultantPlus”, 2005. (in Russian)
Gongalo B.M. Uchenie ob obespechenii obyazatel’stv [The doctrine of securing obligations]. Moscow, Statut Publ., 2002. (in Russian)
Gordeev D.P. Dogovor upravleniya mnogokvartirnym domom: kvalifikaciya, ponyatie i soderzhanie [Management agreement for an apartment building: qualification, concept and content] // Zakony Rossii: opyt, analiz, praktika = Laws of Russia: experience, analysis, practice, 2009, no. 2, 3 (“ConsultantPlus”). (in Russian)
Govorov P.S. Nekotorye problemy pravovogo regulirovaniya deyatel’nosti sportsmenov v komandnyh vidah sporta [Some issues of the legal regulation of the activities of athletes in team sports] // Civilist = Civilist, 2013, no. 1, pp. 109-114. (in Russian)
Grachev N.K. Energoservisnyj dogovor kak razvivayushchijsya institut v rossijskom prave [Energy service agreement as a developing institution in Russian law] // Voprosy rossijskogo i mezhdunarodnogo prava = Issues of Russian and international law, 2018, vol. 8, no. 5A, pp. 149-156. (in Russian)
Gromova E.A. Soglashenie ob osushchestvlenii tekhniko-vnedrencheskoj deyatel’nosti v osobyh ekonomicheskih zonah [The agreement on the implementation of technological development activities in special economic zones]. Moscow, Justicinform Publ., 2015. (in Russian)
Horovater V.G. Sdelki po razmeshcheniyu akcij [Transactions in the placement of shares] // Aktual’nye problemy grazhdanskogo prava = Important problems of civil law, issue 11, collection of articles, ed. O.Yu. Shilohvost. Moscow, Norma Publ., 2007, p. 92-95. (in Russian)
Ioffe O. S. Obyazatel’stvennoe pravo [Law of Obligations]. Moscow, 1975, pp. 33-38. (in Russian)
Ivanova E.V. Raschetnyj forvardnyj kontrakt kak srochnaya sdelka [Settlement forward contract as a forward transaction]. Moscow, Walters Kluver Publ., 2005, pp. 129-139. (in Russian)
Kabatova E.V. Izmenenie roli kollizionnogo metoda v mezhdunarodnom chastnom prave [Changing the role of the collision method in private international law] // Mezhdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo: sovremennaya praktika: Sb. Statej = Private international law: modern practice, collection of articles. Moscow, TON-Ostozhye Publ., 2000, p. 9. (in Russian)
Kachalova A.V. Pravovye osobennosti zaklyucheniya dogovorov o predostavlenii sindicirovannyh kreditov [Legal features of the conclusion of agreements on the provision of syndicated loans] // Zakonodatelstvo = Legislation, 2006, no. 2 (“Garant”). (in Russian)
Kalanda L.V. Problemy pravovogo regulirovaniya hozyajstvennoj (predprinimatel’skoj) deyatel’nosti v neftyanoj otrasli [Issues of legal regulation of economic (entrepreneurial) activities in the oil industry]. Moscow, 2004, p. 130-150. (in Russian)
Kanatov T.K. Realizaciya isklyuchitel’nyh prav avtorov i smezhnyh prav pri dogovornom ispol’zovanii v stranah EAES [The iplementation of exclusive rights of authors and related rights in contract use in the EEU countries] // Evrazijskaya advokatura = Eurasion advocacy, 2017, no. 2 (27), pp. 57-61. (in Russian)
Kanunnikov A.B., Kanunnikov S.A. Grazhdansko-pravovye usloviya v trudovom dogovore s professional’nymi sportsmenami [Civil law conditions in an employment contract with professional athletes] // Trudovoe pravo = Labor Law, 2006, no. 8, p. 10-14. (in Russian)
Karapetov A.G., Savelyev A.I. Svoboda zaklyucheniya nepoimenovannyh dogovorov i ee predely [Freedom of concluding unnamed contracts and its limits] // Vestnik VAS RF = Bulletin of the Higher Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation, 2012, no. 4, pp. 12-56. (in Russian)
Karapetov A.G., Savelyev A.I. Svoboda dogovora i ee predely [The freedom of the contract and its limits], in 2 vols. Moscow, Statut Publ., 2012, vol. 2: [The limits of freedom to determine the terms of the contract in foreign and Russian law] (“ConsultantPlus”). (in Russian)
Khodykin R.M. Kriterij naibolee tesnoj svyazi v mezhdunarodnom chastnom prave [The criterion of the closest connection in private international law] // Moskovskij zhurnal mezhdunarodnogo prava = Moscow Journal of International Law, 2002, no. 4, p. 208-221. (in Russian)
Khokhlov S.A. Konceptual’naya osnova chasti vtoroj Grazhdanskogo kodeksa, Kommentarij k Grazhdanskomu kodeksu Rossijskoj Federacii (chast’ vtoraya) [The conceptual basis of part two of the Civil Code, Commentary on the Civil Code of the Russian Federation (part two)], ed. O. M. Kozyr, A.L. Makovsky, S.A. Khokhlova. Moscow, 1996 (“ConsultantPlus”). (in Russian)
Korneeva S.V. Puti sovershenstvovaniya zakonodatel’stva v sfere investirovaniya v stroitel’stvo [Ways to improve legislation in the field of investment in construction] // Zakonodatelstvo = Legislation, 2008, no. 12 (“Garant”). (in Russian)
Korshunova T.Yu. K voprosu o vozmozhnosti vklyucheniya v trudovoj dogovor uslovij grazhdansko-pravovogo haraktera (na primere diskussii o “zolotyh parashyutah”) [The possibility of including in a labor contract conditions of a civil law nature (for example, the discussion of “golden parachutes”), Civil law and the present time, collection of articles dedicated to the memory of M.I. Braginsky, ed. V.N. Litovkina, K. B. Yaroshenko]. Moscow, Statut Publ., 2013 (“ConsultantPlus”). (in Russian)
Kostkova O.V., Timoshenko V.A. Postatejnyj kommentarij k Federal’nomu zakonu ot 9 iyulya 1993 g. № 5351-1 “Ob avtorskom prave i smezhnyh pravah” [Article-by-article commentary on the Federal Law of 9 July 1993 no. 5351-1 “On Copyright and Related Rights”] (“ConsultantPlus”). (in Russian)
Kozlova E.B. Sistema dogovorov, napravlennyh na sozdanie obektov nedvizhimosti [The system of contracts aimed at creating real estate], Moscow, Contract Publ., 2013. (in Russian)
Kozykin I.V. K voprosu o trudopravovoj prirode transfernogo kontrakta [The question of the employment law nature of the transfer contract] // Molodoj uchenyj = Young scientist, 2016, no. 3-2 (107), pp. 26-29. (in Russian)
Kropotov L.G. Kommercheskie investicii v obekty kapital’nogo stroitel’stva: pravovoe regulirovanie [Commercial investment in capital construction projects: legal regulation], Moscow, Infotropic Media Publ., 2012. (in Russian)
Ksenofontova D.S. Sootnoshenie dogovorov o predostavlenii soderzhaniya v semejnom prave [The ratio of contracts on the provision of support in family law] // Vestnik notarialnoj praktiki = Bulletin of notarial practice, 2011, no 2, pp. 22-24. (in Russian)
Kulakov V.V. Obyazatel’stvo i oslozhneniya ego struktury v grazhdanskom prave Rossii [Obligation and complications of its structure in Russian civil law], 2nd ed. Moscow, RAP, Walters Clover Publ., 2010. (in Russian)
Kuznetsova V.V. Trud rukovoditelya organizacii. Pravovoe regulirovanie [The work of the head of the organization. Legal regulation], ed. Yu.P. Oryol. Moscow, Contract Publ., 2016. (in Russian)
Lebedev V. Istinnye hozyaeva offshorov i antimonopol’noe zakonodatel’stvo (Obzor) [The true owners of offshore and antitrust laws (Review)] // Sliyaniya i pogloscheniya = Mergers and Acquisitions, 2003, no. 2, p. 4-6. (in Russian)
Levushkin A.N., Fedechko F.I. Pravovaya sushchnost’ nepoimenovannogo dogovora i realizaciya ego v ramkah principa svobody dogovora [The legal essence of an unnamed contract and its implementation within the framework of the principle of freedom of contract] // Yuridicheskij mir = Legal World, 2014, no. 4, pp. 27-30. (in Russian)
Luneva E.V. Pravovoj rezhim zemel’nyh uchastkov v osobo ohranyaemyh prirodnyh territoriyah [The legal regime of land in specially protected natural areas], Moscow, Statut Publ., 2018 (“ConsultantPlus”). (in Russian)
Lunts L.A. Kurs mezhdunarodnogo chastnogo prava: v 3-h t. [The course of international private law: in 3 vols]. Moscow, Spark Publ., 2002, p. 237-238. (in Russian)
Lushnikov A.M., Lushnikova M.V. O tolkovanii trudovogo dogovora [On the interpretation of the employment contract, News of universities] // Izvestiya vuzov. Pravovedenie = Bulletin of universities. Jurisprudence, 2005, no. 2, pp. 62-70. (in Russian)
Lushnikov A.M., Lushnikova M.V. Kurs trudovogo prava [The course of labor law], vol. 2, 2009, Moscow, pp. 368-371. (in Russian)
Lushnikov A.M. Razvitie ucheniya o trudovom dogovore v postsovetskij period: obzor nekotoryh problem [The development of the doctrine of the employment contract in the post-Soviet period: an overview of some issues] // Vestnik trudovogo prava i prava sotsialnogo obespecheniya = Herald of labor law and social security law, 2016, no. 10, pp. 26-48. (in Russian)
Maleina M.N. Lichnye neimushchestvennye prava grazhdan: ponyatie, osushchestvlenie, zashchita [Personal non-property rights of citizens: concept, implementation, protection], 2nd ed., revised and enlarged, Moscow, MZ Press Publ., 2001, p. 78-80. (in Russian)
Mazhorina M.V. Vybor primenimogo prava k transgranichnym smeshannym i nepoimenovannym dogovoram [The choice of applicable law to cross-border mixed and unnamed contracts] // Zhurnal rossijskogo prava = Journal of Russian Law, 2012, no. 10, pp. 72-81. (in Russian)
Mikheeva I.E. Garantijnyj depozit v bankovskoj praktike [Security deposit in banking practice] // Yuridicheskaya rabota v kreditnoj organizacii = Legal work in a credit institution, 2014, no. 2 (“Garant”). (in Russian)
Mikheeva L.Yu. Opeka i popechitel’stvo: Teoriya i praktika [Guardianship and trusteeship: Theory and Practice]. Moscow, Walters Kluver Publ., 2004 (“Garant”). (in Russian)
Mikryukov V.A. O mezhotraslevoj analogii v praktike preodoleniya probelov pravovogo regulirovaniya vyplaty “zolotyh parashyutov” [On the interindustry analogy in the practice of overcoming the gaps in the legal regulation of the payment of “golden parachutes”] // Actualnye problem rossijskogo prava = Important Problems of Russian Law, 2018, no. 7 (92), p. 100-107. (in Russian)
Mubarakshina A.M. Pravovaya priroda dogovora surrogatnogo materinstva [The legal nature of surrogacy agreement] // Semejnoe i zhilischnoe pravo = Family and housing law, 2014, no. 4., pp. 24-27. (in Russian)
Naletov K.I. Eshche raz o pravovoj prirode koncessionnogo soglasheniya v sfere nedropol’zovaniya [Once again on the legal nature of the concession agreement in the field of subsoil use] // Zakonodatelstvo i ekonomika = Legislation and Economics, 2005, no. 10, p. 64-73. (in Russian)
Nazarov R. Pravovye problemy deyatel’nosti upravlyayushchih organizacij v svete reshenij sudebnyh organov (vtoraya stat’ya) [Legal issues of the activities of managing organizations in the light of the decisions of the judiciary (second article)] // Zhilischnoe pravo = Housing Law, 2012, no. 9, p. 49-64. (in Russian)
Nettelbladt D. Nachal’noe osnovanie vseobshchej estestvennoj yurisprudencii, prinorovlennoe k upotrebleniyu osnovaniya polozhitel’noj yurisprudencii i perevedennoe s latinskogo yazyka [The initial foundation of universal natural jurisprudence, adapted to the use of the foundation of positive jurisprudence and translated from Latin]. Moscow, 1770, p. 171. (in Russian)
Nobel P. Shvejcarskoe finansovoe pravo i mezhdunarodnye standarty [Swiss financial law and international standards, translation from English]. Мoscow, Walters Kluver Publ., 2007, p. 832-833. (in Russian)
Novitskaya A.A. Nedejstvitel’nost’ chasti sdelki: sravnitel’no-pravovoj analiz rossijskogo i nemeckogo pravovogo regulirovaniya [Invalidity of a part of the transaction: comparative legal analysis of Russian and German legal regulation] // Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava = Bulletin of Civil Law, 2011, no 1, pp. 4-51. (in Russian)
Novitsky I.B., Lunts L.A. Obshcheye ucheniye ob obyazatel’stve [General doctrine of commitment]. Moscow, 1950, p. 102. (in Russian)
Ogorodov D.V., Chelyshev M.Yu. Praktiki [Practices] // Zakonodatelstvo i ekonomika = Legislation and economics, 2005, no. 10, p. 50-53. (in Russian)
Ogorodov D.V., Chelyshev M.Yu. Smeshannye dogovory v chastnom prave: otdel’nye voprosy teorii i praktiki [Mixed contracts in private law: some issues of theory and practice] // Zakonodatel’stvo i ekonomika = Legislation and Economics, 2005, no. 10, pp. 50-53, 53-59. (in Russian)
Ogorodov D.V., Chelyshev M.Yu. Smeshannyj dogovor i voprosy teorii pravovogo regulirovaniya [Mixed contract and questions of the theory of legal regulation] // Zakonodatel’stvo i ekonomika = Legislation and Economics. 2007, no. 3, pp. 49-55. (in Russian)
Ogorodov D.V., Chelyshev M.Yu. K voprosu o vidah smeshannyh dogovorov v chastnom prave [On the issue of the types of mixed contracts in private law] // Zakonodatel’stvo i ekonomika = Legislation and Economics. 2006, no. 2, pp. 53-59. (in Russian)
Ogorodov D.V., Chelyshev M.Yu. O smeshannyh dogovorah v chasti chetvertoj GK RF [On mixed contracts in part four of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation] // Intellektual’naya sobstvennost’. Promyshlennaya sobstvennost’ = Intellectual property. Industrial property. 2007, no. 10, pp. 49-58. (in Russian)
Ogorodov D.V., Chelyshev M.Yu. Nekotorye diskussionnye problemy ucheniya o smeshannyh dogovorah [Some debatable problems of the doctrine of mixed contracts] // Izvestiya vuzov. Pravovedenie = Universities bulletins. Jurisprudence. St Petersburg, 2007, no. 6, pp. 41-63. (in Russian)
Ogorodov D.V., Chelyshev M.Yu. Konstrukciya smeshannogo dogovora v grazhdanskom (chastnom) prave [The design of a mixed contract in civil (private) law] // Sdelki: problemy teorii i praktiki: Sbornik statej = Transactions: problems of theory and practice: Collection of articles, ed. M.A. Rozhkova. Moscow, Statut Publ., 2008, pp. 310-355. (in Russian)
Osipenko K.O. Soglasheniya uchastnikov (akcionerov) v rossijskom i anglijskom prave [Agreements of participants (shareholders) in Russian and English law] // Zakonodatelstvo = Legislation, 2010, no. 4 “Garant”. (in Russian)
Oygenzikht V.A. Netipichnye dogovornye otnosheniya v grazhdanskom prave. Uchebn. posobie. [Atypical contractual relations in civil law. Training allowance]. Dushanbe, 1984. (in Russian)
Pilipson E.G. Genez dogovornogo nasledovaniya i ego pravovaya evolyuciya [The genesis of contractual inheritance and its legal evolution] // Obshchestvennye nauki = Social Sciences, 2016, no. 1, pp. 297-311. (in Russian)
Pischikov V.A. Smeshannye i netipichnye dogovory v grazhdanskom prave Rossii [Mixed and atypical contracts in the civil law of Russia]. Diss. Cand. of Legal Sc. Moscow, 2004, p. 70. (in Russian)
Platonova N. Problemy zakonodatel’nogo regulirovaniya soglashenij o razdele produkcii [Issues of legislative regulation of production sharing agreements] // Ekonomika i pravo = Economy and Law, 1998, no. 3, p. 56-61; no. 4, p. 32-38. (in Russian)
Plieva S.E. Pravovaya priroda brachnogo dogovora v sovremennom semejnom prave Rossii [The legal nature of the marriage contract in modern family law of Russia] // Zakony Rossii: opyt, analiz, praktika = Laws of Russia: experience, analysis, practice, 2014, no. 4, pp. 95-101. (in Russian)
Pokrovsky I.A. Osnovnye problemy grazhdanskogo prava [The main issues of civil law]. Moscow, 1998, pp. 126–127. (in Russian)
Popkova L.A. Pravovaya konstrukciya sindicirovannogo kredita [Legal structure of a syndicated loan], Moscow, Prospect Publ., 2018. (in Russian)
Porotikov A.I. Obychaj v grazhdanskom prave [Custom in civil law], Extended abstract of Cand.Sc. (Law) Dissertation. Moscow, 2003, pp. 19-20. (in Russian)
Mezhdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo: uchebnik [Private international law: Course book], ed. G.K. Dmitrieva, 2nd ed. Moscow, Velby. Prospect Publ., 2008, p. 385-393 (the author of the chapter – G.K. Dmitrieva). (in Russian)
Pykhtin S.V. Smeshannye dogovory s pozicij trebovaniya valyutnogo zakonodatel’stva ob oformlenii pasporta sdelki [Mixed contracts from the standpoint of the requirements of the currency legislation on issuing a transaction passport] // Bankovskoe pravo = Banking law, 2015, vol. 2, pp. 20-24. (in Russian)
Rachkov I., Sorokina A. Belye pyatna v Federal’nom zakone “O koncessionnyh soglasheniyah” [White spots in the Federal Law “On Concession Agreements”] // Zakon = Law, 2007, No. 4, pp. 141-145. (in Russian)
Rainikov A.S. Dogovor kommercheskoj koncessii [Commercial concession agreement]. Moscow, Statut Publ., 2009. (in Russian)
Romanets Yu.V. Sistema dogovorov v grazhdanskom prave Rossii [System of contracts in the civil law of Russia]. Moscow, 2006, pp. 74–80. (in Russian)
Romanets Yu.V. Sistema dogovorov v grazhdanskom prave Rossii [The system of contracts in the civil law of Russia], 2nd ed. Moscow, Norma, Infra-M Publ., 2013. (in Russian)
Rozhkova M.A. Material’nye i processual’nye soglasheniya, poimenovannye v Arbitrazhnom processual’nom kodekse RF [Material and procedural agreements named in the Arbitration Procedure Code of the Russian Federation] // Ekonomka i pravo = Economy and Law, 2004, no. 1, p. 77. (in Russian)
Rozhkova M.A. K voprosu o pravovoj prirode arbitrazhnyh soglashenij [To the question of the legal nature of arbitration agreements] (“ConsultantPlus”). (in Russian)
Rozhkova M.A. Mirovaya sdelka: ispol’zovanie v kommercheskom oborote [A global deal: commercial use]. Moscow, Statut Publ., 2005, § 4.7 Arbitration record (compromise), p. 136-144. (in Russian)
Rybalov A.O. Obyazatel’stva “prostye” i “slozhnye” (nekotorye aspekty spora o ponyatii obyazatel’stva) [“Simple” and “complex” obligations (some aspects of the dispute about the concept of obligation)] // Yurist = Lawyer, 2005, no. 5, pp. 2-7. (in Russian)
Sadikov O.N. Netipichnye instituty v sovetskom grazhdanskom prave [Atypical institutions in Soviet civil law] // Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i pravo = Soviet State and Law, no. 2, 1972, pp. 36–37. (in Russian)
Sadykov Renal R., Sadykov Rishat R. Raschetnyj forvardnyj kontrakt v praktike banka i ego sudebnaya zashchita [The settlement forward contract in bank practice and its judicial protection] // Yuridicheskaya rabota v kreditnoj organizatsii = Legal work in a credit organization, 2009, no. 3 (“Garant”). (in Russian)
Safonova N.S. Smeshannye dogovory s elementami dogovora podryada [Mixed contracts with elements of a contract agreement] // Evrazijskij yuridicheskij zhurnal = Eurasian Law Journal, 2016, no. 2 (93), pp. 194-195. (in Russian)
Salieva R.N. Pravovoe obespechenie razvitiya predprinimatel’stva v neftegazovom sektore ekonomiki [Legal support for the development of entrepreneurship in the oil and gas sector of the economy]. Novosibirsk, 2001. (in Russian)
Savelyev A.I. Otdel’nye voprosy pravovogo regulirovaniya smeshannyh dogovorov v rossijskom i zarubezhnom grazhdanskom prave [Some issues of legal regulation of mixed contracts in Russian and foreign civil law] // Vestnik VAS RF = Bulletin of the Higher Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation, 2011, no. 8, pp. 6-39. (in Russian)
Saveliev D.B. Soglasheniya v semejnoj sfere: Uchebnoe posobie [Family agreements: study guide], Moscow, Prospect Publ., 2017 (“ConsultantPlus”). (in Russian)
Sergeev A., Tereshchenko T. Dogovor arendy imushchestva s pravom vykupa [Contract of property lease with the option to purchase] // Corporativnyj yurist = Corporate Lawyer, 2007, no. 1, p. 44–45. (in Russian)
Shaburov A.S. Formal’naya opredelennost’ prava [Formal certainty of law]. Diss. Cand. of legal sciences. Sverdlovsk, 1973. (in Russian)
Shemeneva O.N. Diskussionnye voprosy koncepcii processual’nyh soglashenij v trudah rossijskih uchenyh [Discussion issues of the concept of procedural agreements in the works of Russian scholars] // Vestnik Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, seriya: Pravo = Herald of Voronezh State University, Series: Law, 2016, no. 2 (25), pp. 110- 120. (in Russian)
Shershenevich G.F. Kurs torgovogo prava [Commercial law course]. 4th ed., vol. 2 // Tovar. Torgovye sdelki = Product. Trade deals. St. Petersburg, 1908, pp. 240–241. (in Russian)
Shevchuk S. Nekotorye problemy pravovogo regulirovaniya primeneniya iskusstvennyh metodov reprodukcii [Some issues of legal regulation of the use of artificial reproduction methods] // Yurist = Lawyer, 2002, no. 9, p. 60-63. (in Russian)
Shitkina I.S. Otdel’nye problemy pravovogo regulirovaniya obrazovaniya i deyatel’nosti edinolichnogo ispolnitel’nogo organa [Some problems of legal regulation of education and activities of the sole executive body] // Ekonomika i pravo = Economy and Law, 2011, no. 4, pp. 3-17. (in Russian)
Shitkina I.S. Glava XII. Pravovoe obespechenie korporativnogo upravleniya [Chapter XII. Legal support of corporate governance, Corporate law: training course: in 2 volumes], E.G. Afanasyeva, V.A. Waipan, A.V. Gabov and others, ed. I.S. Shitkina. Moscow, Statut Publ., 2018, vol. 2. (in Russian)
Shitkina I.S. Pravovaya priroda i procedura korporativnogo oformleniya dogovora o sozdanii konsolidirovannoj gruppy nalogoplatel’shchikov [The legal nature and procedure for corporate registration of an agreement on the creation of a consolidated group of taxpayers] // Ekonomika i pravo = Economy and Law, 2012, no. 5, pp. 3-23. (in Russian)
Simolin A. Smeshannye dogovory i ucheniya ob otdel’nyh obyazannostyah [Mixed treaties and exercises on individual liability] // Pravo, ezhenedelnaya yuridicheskaya gazeta = Law. Weekly legal newspaper, 1911. No. 47, art. 2619-2626. (in Russian)
Simolin A. Dogovor smeshannogo dareniya [Mixed gift agreement] // Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava = Bulletin of civil law. 1917, no. 3-5, pp. 26–48. (in Russian)
Sinaisky V.I. Russkoe grazhdanskoe pravo [Russian Civil Law]. Vol. II // Obyazatel’stvennoe, semejnoe i nasledstvennoe pravo = Obligatory, family and inheritance law. Kiev, 1915, pp. 87–90. (in Russian)
Sobchak A.A. Smeshannye i kompleksnye dogovory v grazhdanskom prave [Mixed and complex contracts in civil law] // Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i pravo = Soviet State and Law, No. 11, 1989, pp. 61–66. (in Russian)
Sphera svobody [The sphere of freedom] / Em V. S., Komarova T. E., Simolin A.V. // Simolin A.A. Vozmezdnost’, bezvozmezdnost’, smeshannye dogovory i inye teoreticheskie problemy grazhdanskogo prava [Retribution, gratuitousness, mixed contracts and other theoretical problems of civil law]. Collection of works. Moscow, 2005, pp. 7–47. (in Russian)
Stepanov D.I. Uslugi kak obekt grazhdanskih prav [Services as an object of civil rights]. Moscow, 2005, p. 209. (in Russian)
Sukhanov E.A. O vidah sdelok v germanskom i v rossijskom grazhdanskom prave [On types of transactions in German and Russian civil law] // Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava = Bulletin of civil law, 2006, no. 2. p. 5-26. (in Russian)
Tal L.S. Polozhitel’noe pravo i neuregulirovannye dogovory [Positive law and unsettled contracts] // Yuridicheskie zapiski Demidovskogo yuridicheskogo liceya = Legal notes of Demidov Law Lyceum. Vol. III (XIII), Yaroslavl, 1912, pp. 386-434. (in Russian)
Tarasenko Yu.A. Smeshannyj dogovor [Mixed contract] // Arbitrazhnoe pravosudie v Rossii = Arbitration justice in Russia, 2007, no. 4. (in Russian)
Tarusina N.N., Lushnikov A.M., Lushnikova M.V. Social’nye dogovory v prave [Social contracts in law]. Moscow, Prospect Publ., 2017. (in Russian)
Trotsenko O.S. K voprosu o kompleksnoj pravovoj prirode soglasheniya o gosudarstvenno- chastnom partnerstve [The question of complex legal nature of public-private partnership agreements] // Yuridicheskaya mysl = Legal thought, 2018, no 5 (109), pp. 74-79. (in Russian)
Uralova A.A. Smeshannyj dogovor v obhod zakona [Mixed contract bypassing the law] // Yurist = Lawyer, 2014, no. 3, pp. 13-15. (in Russian)
Vasilchenko D.D. O priobretenii i otchuzhdenii dolej (akcij) v dogovore ob osushchestvlenii prav uchastnikov obshchestva [On the acquisition and alienation of shares (stocks) in an agreement on the exercise of the rights of members of a company] // Pravo i politika = Law and Politics, 2017, no. 4, pp. 158-171. (in Russian)
Vasilevskaya L.Yu. Uchenie o veshchnyh sdelkah po germanskomu pravu [Doctrine on property transactions under German law]. Moscow, Statut Publ., 2004. (in Russian)
Vaskevich V.P. O dogovornom regulirovanii professional’noj sportivnoj deyatel’nosti [Contractual regulation of professional sports activities] // Zakony Rossii: opyt, analiz, praktika = Laws of Russia: experience, analysis, practice, 2009, no. 1 (“ConsultantPlus”). (in Russian)
Vaskevich V.P. Grazhdansko-pravovoe regulirovanie otnoshenij v oblasti professional’- nogo sporta [Civil law regulation of relations in the field of professional sports]: Diss. Cand. Legal Scien. Kazan, 2006, p. 10, 17-18. (in Russian)
Vaskevich V.P., Chelyshev M.Yu. Pravovoe regulirovanie professional’nogo sporta [Legal regulation of professional sports] // Rossijskaya yusticiya = Russian Justice, 2001, no. 7, p. 35-36. (in Russian)
Vavilin E.V. Arenda transportnyh sredstv: Pravovye aspekty [Rental of vehicles: Legal aspects]. Moscow, Alfa-Press Publ., 2005, pp. 59-71. (in Russian)
Veliaminov G., Mezhdunarodnoe ekonomicheskoe pravo i process: Uchebnik [International Economic Law and Process: Course book]. Moscow, Volters Kluver Publ., 2004, § 589-589 (“Garant”). (in Russian)
Vitko V.S. Grazhdansko-pravovaya priroda licenzionnogo dogovora [Civil law nature of the license agreement]. Moscow, Statut Publ., 2012. (in Russian)
Vitko V.S. Pravovaya priroda otnoshenij po sozdaniyu sluzhebnyh proizvedenij [The legal nature of relations in the creation of official publications] // Ekonomika i pravo = Economy and Law, 2018, no. 9 (500), pp. 69-78. (in Russian)
Vitko V.S., Tsaturyan E.A. Yuridicheskaya priroda dogovorov autsorsinga i autstaffinga [Legal nature of outsourcing and outstaffing contracts], Moscow, Statut Publ., 2012. (in Russian)
Voznesenskaya N.N. Soglasheniya o razdele produkcii v sfere neftedobychi [Agreements on production sharing in oil industry]. Moscow, 1997. (in Russian)
Yurieva L.A. Dogovor upravleniya mnogokvartirnym domom [Management agreement for an apartment building], ed. I.D. Kuzmina, Moscow, Justicinform Publ., 2011. (in Russian)
Zhalinsky A., Roericht A. Vvedenie v nemeckoe pravo [Introduction to German law]. Moscow, Spark Publ., 2001, p. 322-323, 421-422. (in Russian)
Zubareva O.G. Pravovaya priroda dogovora ob osushchestvlenii opeki ili popechitel’stva (dogovora o priemnoj sem’e) [The legal nature of the agreement on the implementation of guardianship or wardship (foster family agreement)] // Zakonodatelstvo = Legislation, 2011, no. 3 (“Garant”). (in Russian)
Zvekov V.P. Kollizii zakonov v mezhdunarodnom chastnom prave [Conflicts of laws in private international law]. Moscow, Walters Kluver Publ., 2007, p. 133-135. (in Russian)

Information about the author
Dmitriy Ogorodov (Moscow, Russia) – Candidate of Legal Sciences, Arbitrator of the International Commercial Arbitration Court at the Chamber of Commerce and Industry of the Russian Federation (6/1, Ilyinka St., 109012, Moscow, building1; e-mail: d.ogorodov@gmail.com).

Recommended citation
Ogorodov D.V. Mixed contracts in the Russian legal doctrine: contribution of Kazan civil law science. Kazan University Law Review. 2019; 4 (4): 281-329. https:// doi.org/10.30729/2541-8823-2019-4-4-281-329



Our Partners